If an examiner just told you “not qualified” or “pending,” you probably want to know what happens if you fail a DOT physical. You leave without a medical certificate, and the examiner reports the result to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). It is not always the end of the road. FMCSA says some conditions are reversible, and an exemption or a new exam may be possible.
Quick answer
What happens if you fail a DOT physical?
If a certified medical examiner finds you do not meet FMCSA standards, you get no medical certificate and the examiner must report it to FMCSA. Since June 23, 2025, any earlier certificate is no longer valid. You can treat the problem, apply for an exemption if one fits, or get a new exam.

What happens if you fail a DOT physical?
Under 49 CFR 391.43, an examiner who finds you not physically qualified must tell you and tell you it will be reported to FMCSA. From June 23, 2025, the rule adds that all medical certificates issued to you before are no longer valid.
FMCSA’s Medical Examiner’s Handbook (2024 Edition) says the examiner must not issue a certificate, Form MCSA-5876, but still uploads the result to the National Registry. The examiner should explain the reasons and any steps that could help you meet the standards. The handbook notes that some conditions are reversible with successful treatment.
See the 13 FMCSA standards that can disqualify a driver.
The results an examiner can give
“Fail” is not one of the boxes. FMCSA’s handbook describes these results on the Medical Examination Report Form, MCSA-5875.
| Result | What it means | What happens next |
|---|---|---|
| Meets standards | Qualified for 2 years | Renew before the card expires |
| Meets standards, periodic monitoring | Qualified for a shorter time the examiner sets | Return sooner for a new exam |
| Meets standards with an exemption or SPE certificate | Qualified only if FMCSA grants it | Apply to FMCSA |
| Determination pending | More information needed | Up to 45 days to provide it |
| Does not meet standards | Not qualified, with the reason given | No certificate, reported to FMCSA |
| Incomplete examination | The exam was not finished | A new exam is needed |
For the whole visit, see each step of a DOT physical.

Determination pending: can you still drive?
If your current card still has time left, FMCSA’s handbook says you are eligible to keep driving while the exam is pending. Pending does not extend that expiration date, and no new certificate is issued until the decision is made.
Under 49 CFR 391.43, the examiner must tell you that the information or further testing must be done within 45 days. The handbook adds these rules:
- The examiner may set a return date sooner than 45 days.
- Only an examiner in the same practice may finish a pending exam.
- If nothing is updated by day 45, FMCSA writes to you and the examiner that the exam is no longer valid, and you need a new one.
- A failed vision or hearing screening is not put on pending. You see a specialist, then return for a new exam.

A shorter card is not a failure
A 1-year or 3-month card means you met the standards. FMCSA’s handbook says examiners may certify for less than the 24-month maximum when they want to monitor a condition, such as high blood pressure (see DOT blood pressure requirements). Read how long a DOT medical card lasts to plan your next exam.

Can you get a second opinion?
Yes, with limits. FMCSA’s handbook says the rules do not stop you from getting a second exam from another certified examiner. You are expected to give both examiners the same medical information. An examiner must not certify someone whose information they believe is untrue.
Your employer may require the second exam from its preferred certified examiner. If a certificate is issued, the handbook says the employer decides which one to accept.
The formal disagreement process
A separate rule, 49 CFR 391.47, covers a disagreement between your examiner and your motor carrier’s examiner. The application to FMCSA must include a report from an impartial specialist. Once it is filed, the rule says the driver is treated as disqualified until FMCSA decides.

How to fix the problem and go back
Start with what the examiner said was missing, and work on it with your treating clinician:
- Get the records, test results or specialist notes the examiner asked for.
- Insulin users: Form MCSA-5870 from the clinician who manages insulin. See DOT physicals with diabetes.
- Vision problems: Form MCSA-5871 from an eye doctor. See the DOT vision requirements.
- Hearing, seizure or limb problems: ask FMCSA about a Federal exemption or skill performance evaluation (SPE) certificate.
The handbook says only FMCSA grants exemptions, and only for interstate drivers. The rules and handbook we read set no waiting period before a new exam. Find a certified examiner on the National Registry, as explained in whether your family doctor can do a DOT physical, and pack what to bring to a DOT physical.
What happens to your CDL record
FMCSA’s National Registry II fact sheet for drivers (May 2025) says results for CDL and learner’s permit holders, including “medically unqualified,” go electronically to the state licensing agency. When an exemption is needed, the result is sent after FMCSA issues it.
What the state does next is up to the state. In Illinois, check with the Secretary of State, and read how an Illinois CDL medical card reaches the Secretary of State.

Frequently asked questions
Does a failed DOT physical get reported?
Yes. Under 49 CFR 391.43, the examiner must tell you that a not qualified result will be reported to FMCSA. FMCSA’s May 2025 fact sheet says results for CDL and learner’s permit holders, including medically unqualified ones, are sent electronically to the state licensing agency and posted on the driver record.
Can I drive while my DOT physical is pending?
FMCSA’s 2024 handbook says drivers are eligible to keep driving on time left on their current medical certificate while an exam is pending. The pending status does not extend that expiration date. If your card has expired, you need a completed exam with a qualified result first.
How long after failing a DOT physical can you retake it?
The FMCSA rules and handbook we read set no waiting period. A new exam makes sense once the problem has been addressed and you have the records the examiner asked for. Give the new examiner the same medical information you gave the first one.
Can I see a different examiner after failing?
Yes. FMCSA’s handbook says the rules do not prohibit a second exam from another certified examiner, but you must give the same medical information to both. Your employer may require its preferred examiner and decides which certificate to accept. Ask your employer first.
Will I lose my CDL if I fail a DOT physical?
FMCSA sends the result to your state licensing agency, and the state decides what happens to your license. In Illinois, check with the Secretary of State. FMCSA.s handbook says some conditions are reversible, and you can be examined again after treatment or with an exemption.
Working on a health issue after your DOT physical?
Your family doctor can help with blood pressure, blood sugar, sleep or hearing concerns and gather the records an examiner asked for. Contact our office to schedule a visit.
Next, review how the DOT hearing test works if hearing was the issue.
Sources
- Code of Federal Regulations, 49 CFR 391.43, “Medical examination; certificate of physical examination” (govinfo.gov), checked November 21, 2026.
- Code of Federal Regulations, 49 CFR 391.47, “Resolution of conflicts of medical evaluation,” checked November 21, 2026.
- Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, “Medical Examiner’s Handbook 2024 Edition” (January 2024), checked November 21, 2026.
- FMCSA National Registry, “National Registry II: Fact Sheet for Drivers” (May 2025), checked November 21, 2026.
This article is general health information, not medical advice, and does not replace a visit. If you think you have an emergency, call 911. For questions about your own health, contact your doctor’s office.

